StudyFinds searched the web to find the consensus best small towns in America, according to travel experts. Let’s get to our list of the five best small towns in America, according to experts. Of course, we want your opinion, so comment below to let us know which small town tops the list in your eyes! Sedona, ArizonaIf you’re looking to head west, this town with a population of just 9700 people landed on just about every expert’s list of the best small towns in America. Far & Wide think this best of the best small towns in America deserves more attention than it gets: “Aspen and Boulder usually get all the attention in Colorado, but Telluride — more quaint, less pricey — deserves love too.